Consumerdriven health care is the euphemism for highdeductible health plans with savings accounts. The threats facing our public health care programs and a rightsbased response. For example, people enrolled in consumer driven health plans may benefit from information that would help them determine whether or not they need to see a doctor e. Consumerdriven health plans generally are not marketed to employers as an immediate solution to their rising health care costs, but rather as a constructive employer response to employee demands for more choice, fewer restrictions, and less involvement on the part. Herzlinger is a business researcher, and the contributors are largely wideeyed. Implications for providers, payers, and policymakers. Some key observations consumerdriven healthcare cdh is an approach to health coverage and service delivery that focuses on motivating consumers to become more actively engaged in their health and wellbeing. Hdhps are sometimes called catastrophiconly and, as the name would indicate, they always come with higher.
Both can drive higher participation ratesa measure of successful cdhp programs. The goal of the series is to help employers and plan managers assess both the positive and negative consequences of cdhps, and to recommend steps they can take to better equip employees to be informed. Consumerdriven health plans cdhps have surpassed health maintenance organizations hmos to become the second most common plan design offered by u. Consumer driven health plans hsa, hra, fsa ebso, inc. A consumer driven health plan cdhp is a plan that enables you to make decisions about your health care and how you pay for care. Consumerdriven healthcare cdhc, or consumerdriven health plans cdhp refers to a type of health insurance plan that allows members to use health savings accounts hsas, health reimbursement accounts hras, or similar medical payment accounts to pay routine healthcare expenses directly, but a highdeductible health plan protects them from more costly medical expenses. The kansas city business journal features local business news about kansas city. Highdeductible health plan hdhp and health savings account hsa basics duration. This is consumerdriven health plans by bswh corporate communications on vimeo, the home for high quality videos and the people who love them. It appears highdeductible health plans are here to stay.
Successful implementation of the consumerdriven health. Driven health care a short history of american health economics. Most employees save money with a cdhp, but only you can determine what health plan best meets your need. Its been 10 years since the concept of consumer driven health plans cdhps first grabbed hold of the conversation in the group employee benefits industry. These plans try to control expenses by giving policyholders more responsibility for their health insurance spending. Summary of consumer driven health plans health fsa. The satisfaction gap is narrowing between employees with traditional health insurance plans and those with consumerdriven health plans cdhps, consisting of highdeductible coverage plus a.
These products were designed to engage consumer s more directly in their health care purchases. Consumerdriven health plans reduce medical care utilization. After a lot of chatter back in 2003 and 2004, consumer driven health had moved to the backburner, at least in terms of industry buzz. What is it, and what does it mean for employees and employers. Feb 14, 2005 the kansas city business journal features local business news about kansas city.
Professor herzlinger documents how the consumerdriven health caremovement is being implemented and its impact on insurers,providers, new intermediaries, and governments. Consumer experiences in a consumerdriven health plan. Consumerdriven health plans what is a consumerdriven health plan cdhp. Nov 18, 2015 the importance of both communication about consumerdirected healthcare plans cdhps and access to the latest tools to help employees get the most from cdhps. The combination of responsibility plus education emphasized in the consumer survival kit will enhance the effectiveness of consumerdriven health plans. Consumer driven health plans what is a consumer driven health plan cdhp. This book is a history of how and why the united states became so. In the book, herzlinger describes the health care system of. October 25, 2010 some employers are considering the switch to consumerdriven health plans cdhps in order to reduce the cost of providing health insurance benefits to their employees. The growing role of consumerdriven health plans its still unclear what can or will change with governmentissued health care reform. Consumerdriven health plans continue to gain ground in. Consumer driven health care plans interactive medical systems. Lischko provides a historical perspective on cdhc in.
A cdhp is a health insurance plan that pays for covered services after you the deductible is met. It is based on the theory that increased financial exposure will encourage patients to. Jan 27, 2011 highdeductible health plan hdhp and health savings account hsa basics duration. The recent release of the benefitfocus whitepaper, losing control of costs. Some key observations consumer driven healthcare cdh is an approach to health coverage and service delivery that focuses on motivating consumers to become more actively engaged in their health and wellbeing. Heres a closer look at the consumerdirected health plan also referred to as a consumerdriven health plan cdhp, which is in a category of plans called high deductible health plans hdhps. Consumerdriven health plans steer whole new course kansas. We have been proudly serving americas workforce since 1960. Consumerdriven health plans reduce medical care utilization research shows that consumerdriven health plans lead individuals to use fewer. Successful implementation of the consumerdriven health plan. Using a combination of nurse triage, healthcare information and disease management programs, the consumer survival kit is a must for any serious consumer driven health plan. Although considerable research has been conducted on cdhps, significant gaps remain in our understanding of them. In addition, since the field is still in its infancy, dr.
Consumer directed health plans, or cdhps, use federallyestablished funding tools, such as flexible spending accounts fsas, health savings accounts hsas, and health reimbursement arrangements hras, to give the consumer more power in managing health care and its associated costs. These plans may encourage members to seek better value for health expenditures but may also decrease essential care. An international comparative study and disentitlement. The combination of responsibility plus education emphasized in the consumer survival kit will enhance the effectiveness of consumer driven health plans. The pretax dollars set aside for medical expenses are kept in a health savings account hsa or a health reimbursement account hra. Implications for providers, payers, and policy makers. The goal of these plans was to add a financial burden on consumers so that they would make more informed choices about their health care instead of overutilizing services. Consumerdriven health care the first time around health. Ebia consumerdriven health care law firms pension and. The satisfaction gap is narrowing between employees with traditional health insurance plans and those with consumer driven health plans cdhps, consisting of highdeductible coverage plus a. The goal of these plans is to reduce costs for employers, prompt employees to make more educated decisions about the care they seek, and increase the percentage of employees that have access to insurance. With additionalcontributions by health cares leading strategists,innovators, regulators and scholars, consumer driven healthcare presents a compelling vision of a health care system builtto satisfy the people it serves.
Apwu health plan is a national preferred provider organization ppo offering both a feeforservice high option health plan and a consumer driven option health plan. Consumerdriven health care by herzlinger, regina e. Consumerdriven healthcare cdhc, or consumerdriven health plans cdhp refers to a type of health insurance plan that allows members to use health. Buying health insurance can be very confusing, and we all want to choose the best plans for our needs. Comparing divergent privatization approaches in chile, colombia, and. For example, you have a choice to 1 either pay more up front in premiums from your paycheck and less when you actually receive care lower deductible or 2 less up front in premiums from your paycheck and more when you actually receive care higher deductible. Gandolfo svp, senior consulting manager pnc bank james. May 19, 2008 consumerdriven health care is the euphemism for highdeductible health plans with savings accounts. This paper reports marketplace developments for consumerdriven health plans in spring 2002.
Who wins, who loses in the transformation of americas largest service industry. Cdhps are a small, though apparently growing segment of the employer sponsored health insurance market. Conferences on consumerdriven health care are noteworthy by both their. The future of consumerdriven health plans tony novak. Success tips for consumerdirected healthcare plans cdhps. The first consumer d irected health plans cdhp were introduced by health e commerce ventures in the late 1990s. Impact of emerging health insurance arrangements on. Consumer driven health care, high deductible health plans. The paradigmatic insurance plan for consumerdriven health care is the hdhp. Pdf this paper analyzes the evolution of consumerdriven health care in terms of. Cdhps have generally been found to be more effective than traditional plans in terms of reducing total medical cost, especially in the short term.
Among contemporary american academic health policy commentators,1 foundation researchers, 2 and liberal think tank analysts,3 the concept of consumer driven also known as consumerdirected health care is a subject of great. The paradigmatic insurance plan for consumer driven health care is the hdhp. Professor herzlinger documents how the consumer driven health caremovement is being implemented and its impact on insurers,providers, new intermediaries, and governments. Consumerdriven health plans generally are not marketed to employers as an immediate solution to their rising health care costs, but rather as a constructive employer response to employee demands for more choice, fewer restrictions, and less involvement on the part of employers and health plans in health care decisions. In our next installment in our series on the evolution of consumer driven health plans we will assess the impact of cdhps on employee finances, health and satisfaction. Consumerdirected health plans combine lower premiums with high annual deductibles, internetbased qualityofcare information, and health savings mechanisms. The ethical foundations of consumerdriven health care. Consumerdriven health planstaxadvantaged accounts paired with highdeductible coveragerepresent a small but rapidly growing part of insurance offerings. Successful implementation of the consumerdriven health plan cdhp 2 flight attendant. Here we will explore the trends that have led to a dramatic rise in consumer driven health plans cdhps and the impact these plans are having on employees.
Nalc health benefit plan consumer driven health plan cdhp and value option plan pg. A health flexible spending account fsa is a tax arrangement authorized under section 125 of the internal revenue code that allows for pretax funding of an account via participation payroll reductions or employer contributions to cover eligible health care expenses, as definted within the parameters section 2d. The goal of the series is to help employers and plan managers assess both the positive and negative consequences of cdhps, and to recommend steps they can take to better equip employees to be informed healthcare consumers. Consumer driven health plans cdhps have been on the rise as one possible solution. Sep 14, 2016 consumer driven health plans reduce medical care utilization research shows that consumer driven health plans lead individuals to use fewer medical services while spending 1. Boston as part of a push to contain health care cost growth, business leaders, state administrators, and policymakers should focus on consumer driven health care cdhc plans that involve consumers in making health care decisions, according to a pioneer institute report issued today.
Cdhps have generally been found to be more effective than traditional plans in terms of reducing total medical cost, especially in. Consumerdriven health plans steer whole new course. Consumer driven health care is a name for the practice of setting up employee health plans with low premiums, high deductibles, and savings accounts. Individuals covered as selfonly have an individual deductible amount and those covered as family self plus one other individual have a family deductible. Evolution of consumer driven health plans blog series. He is the author of health care coverage determinations. Consumerdriven health plans cdhps were created to help combat rising health care costs, as well as to provide consumers with increased transparency and control over their health care expenditures. Healthcare spending the factsthis is the first in our fivepart series, the evolution of consumer driven health plans.
What two elements are combined in consumerdriven health plans. Dec 11, 2012 boston as part of a push to contain health care cost growth, business leaders, state administrators, and policymakers should focus on consumer driven health care cdhc plans that involve consumers in making health care decisions, according to a pioneer institute report issued today. Consumerdirected health plans, or cdhps, use federallyestablished funding tools, such as flexible spending accounts fsas, health savings accounts hsas, and health reimbursement arrangements hras, to give the consumer more power in managing health care and its associated costs. This paper analyzes the evolution of consumerdriven health care in terms of its original vision, its subsequent. As health care costs continue to rise, americans are looking for alternatives to traditional insurance. See discussion of united resource networks at multiple points in the book. Growth of consumer driven health plansthis is the third in our fivepart series, the evolution of consumer driven health plans. Findings are from interviews with executives from startup and health insurance firms, benefit.
This paper reports marketplace developments for consumer driven health plans in spring 2002. The rise of consumer driven health plans corporate synergies. Consumerdriven health care builds on her popular 1997 book marketdriven health care. This paper outlines some novel insights into what works with cdhps and how to make them more effective. This is the first in our fivepart series, the evolution of consumer driven health plans. For the past fifteen years, a relatively small but growing number of businesses have been offering an alternative to traditional employermanaged health care. How do consumer driven health plans compare to traditional. Consumer driven health care a proven costsaving strategy. This situation makes it difficult for business owners to plan their benefits because no one knows what the future will look like. In time, consumerdriven plans were the only option for many americans regardless of their age, health status, or income. Since 2008, enrollment in socalled consumerdriven plans has grown 10 percent per year in connecticut as companies have felt the. The threats facing our public healthcare programs and a rightsbased response. The normative implications of consumerdriven health plans. Consumer driven healthcare cdhc, or consumer driven health plans cdhp refers to a type of health insurance plan that allows members to use health savings accounts hsas, health reimbursement accounts hras, or similar medical payment accounts to pay routine healthcare expenses directly, but a highdeductible health plan protects them from more costly medical expenses.
Consumerdriven health plans cdhp consumerdriven health plans cdhp are a category of health insurance plans that combine a high deductible amount with a savings account to pay for a portion of medical expenses with pretax dollars. Data from the 2005 kaiserhret employer survey, a wellregarded survey, suggest that among employers offering health benefits, 1. Consumer driven health plans cdhps have surpassed health maintenance organizations hmos to become the second most common plan design offered by u. High deductible health plans history, present and future. Cdhps are a combination of a highdeductible health insurance plan with savings accounts for health care like a health savings account hsa, health reimbursement account hra or flexible spending account fsa. With additionalcontributions by health cares leading strategists,innovators, regulators and scholars, consumerdriven healthcare presents a compelling vision of a health care system builtto satisfy the people it serves. For qualified large employers, an increasingly common solution is to offer consumer driven health plans cdhps, which are better known as high deductible health plans hdhps. The consumer driven health plan cdhp is a qualified highdeductible health plan coupled with a taxfavored health savings account hsa or health reimbursement arrangement hra. More employees satisfied with consumerdriven health plans. Responding to persistently rising health care costs and continuing concerns about the quality of health care, many health insurance purchasers have become. Consumer take the wheel, reminds us of the importance of both communication about consumerdirected healthcare plans cdhps and access to the latest tools to help employees get the most from cdhps. Consumerdriven healthcare cdhc, or consumerdriven health plans cdhp refers to a type of health insurance plan that allows members to use health savings accounts hsas, health reimbursement accounts hras, or similar medical payment accounts to pay routine healthcare expenses directly, but a highdeductible health plan protects them from more. Consumerdriven health care plans low premiums, high deductibles and savings accounts promised to reduce employer costs, turn.
A consumer driven health plan cdhp refers to a type of health insurance and benefits program introduced in 2001. A consumerdriven health plan cdhp is a plan that enables you to make decisions about your health care and how you pay for care. Among contemporary american academic health policy commentators,1 foundation researchers, 2 and liberal think tank analysts,3 the concept of consumer driven also known as consumer directed health care is a subject of great. Most employees save money with a cdhp, but only you can determine what health plan best meets your. He is the editor of readings in comparative health law and bioethics and a coauthor of health law. This is the third in our fivepart series, the evolution of consumer driven health plans.
Introduced in the early 2000s, consumerdriven health plans cdhps brought with them the potential to keep escalating health care costs under control. The origins of consumerdriven health care a short history of american health economics. Kevin a mckechnie executive director, american bankers association h. In time, as more people were forced into the consumerdriven plans, the deductibles and out of. A consumer driven health plan cdhp is an excellent option and a very effective tool for monitoring health care costs. Cigna has provided an annual analysis on consumerdriven health plans cdhps and associated medical claims for the last eight studies. Consumerdriven health care is a name for the practice of setting up employee health plans with low premiums, high deductibles, and savings accounts. Managedcare plans would see a death spiral as the consumerdriven plans cherrypicked the youngest and healthiest customers.
273 1544 893 1467 752 916 1278 1327 1554 1230 417 633 1023 1247 1244 417 367 1121 1361 34 869 1145 887 1198 607 185 1276 21 1292 666 436 450 371 1442 509 510 282 570 131